Nature has produced most natural molecules as chiral objects, which means the molecule can come in two enantiomeric forms, each being the mirror image of the other. When a natural product is synthesised in a laboratory, a chiral synthesis means just one form is made, and then is compared with the natural product to see if it matches. Just such a process was following in the recent synthesis of cylindricine, a marine alkaloid[1] featured on the ACS molecule-of-the-week site. The authors noted that the absolute configuration of cylindricine as isolated naturally had remained unassigned, and as it happens one way of measuring the properties of the individual enantiomer – its optical rotation – had not been determined. So in part, the purpose of this synthesis was to determine the absolute configuration of this molecule. Here I explore this process.
There are several different procedures for finding the absolute configuration of a molecule.
Any or all of methods 3-5 could be used to independently check on the results inferred in procedure 1. Here I report the results of such an attempted verification.
The start point is an attempt to find the most stable conformation of cylindricine. Here I am using a conformational tool called GMMX, part of the Gaussview suite. Loading the molecule as drawn above, six rotatable bonds are automatically identified and the program systematically rotates about all of these in turn using a molecular mechanics force field to compute an energy. This field includes so-called dispersion or van der Waals attractions. I used the MMFF94 force field, with its origins in the pharmaceutical industries and reasonably suitable for a natural product. The lowest energy conformation obtained is shown below, but it should be noted that there are 36 further conformations within 3.5 kcal/mol of the lowest. This conformer was chosen for the chiroptical calculations described in 3-5 above. Of course, more thoroughly all the conformers with a population of at least 1% should be included in this process for a more comprehensive analysis.
To get an inkling of why this conformer might be the lowest in energy, inspect the model below (click on the image to get a 3D rotatable model). It shows the so-called NCI (non-covalent-interactions), which are mostly composed of hydrogen bond and dispersion stabilisations. Each little blue/green isosurface is one of these – and the more of them there are – the more stable the conformer.
For this conformer, the calculated optical rotation emerge as -34° at 589nm (FAIR Data DOI: 10.14469/hpc/12231). The reported value is -8.5°. You might think that the agreement is poor, but such calculations are only reasonably clear-cut for large values of the rotations! Clearly, this calculation provides some supporting evidence that the assignment of absolute configuration is correct. The take home message is not the value of the rotation but its sign, where calculation and measurement agree. The next step would be to perform a full conformational average over all 37 conformations!
The calculated ECD spectrum is shown below. It only shows a weak negative feature at ~220nm and strong evidence requires features at >280nm to be clear cut. This result suggests that recording this spectrum is not recommended.
The VCD spectrum is shown below. This does show strong features in both the C-H stretching region and the 1500-800 wavenumber region and would be a good diagnostic. Recording it would indirectly also reveal whether the conformer chosen above is likely to be correct or not.
So the above provides a start point for a more comprehensive and independent method for verifying the absolute configuration. The total synthesis using a starting material of known configuration it has to be said is normally pretty reliable, but there are rare examples where a mistake in assignment was made of such a precursor and which was indeed corrected by VCD assignment.[5]
This blog has DOI: 10.14469/hpc/12233
In the mid to late 1990s as the Web developed, it was becoming more obvious…
I have written a few times about the so-called "anomeric effect", which relates to stereoelectronic…
The recent release of the DataCite Data Citation corpus, which has the stated aim of…
Following on from my template exploration of the Wilkinson hydrogenation catalyst, I now repeat this…
In the late 1980s, as I recollected here the equipment needed for real time molecular…
On 24th January 1984, the Macintosh computer was released, as all the media are informing…